How to Test Ad Creatives for Paid Social Each Week

Testing ad creatives doesn’t need to feel complicated or time-consuming. At 5th Element Media, we use a simple weekly system adapted for franchise businesses that lets us generate dozens of ad variations, launch them cleanly, analyze performance fast, and confidently scale the winners.

In this article, I’ll break down the exact process we use for franchisees – the same method we use to test and scale ads for brands like IMAGE Studios and others.

‍

‍

1. Build Your Test Batch the Right Way

Before anything else, you need creatives - but not in the traditional “record one perfect video” sense. Instead, break your content into three simple building blocks:

• Hooks (the first 1–3 seconds that stop the scroll)
• Meats (the core message or offer)
• CTAs ("click below to book your tour", etc.)

Create them separately, then recombine them into dozens of variations.

‍

Here’s our weekly prep workflow:

• Brainstorm 50 hooks, 3–4 meats, and 3–4 CTAs
• Film all your hooks at once
• Film your meats next
• Film your CTAs last
• Stitch combinations together in CapCut
• Label each video as “Ad# – Hook – Meat” so you can track performance later

‍

This modular approach lets you generate ad volume without needing a full production shoot every time.

Why this works especially well for franchisees:
Inside our agency, we coach franchise owners 1:1 on this recording method, and we fill the gaps with professionally shot content in our in-house studio. This lets us build large test batches quickly without depending on owners to deliver new footage every week.

‍

2. Launch Your Campaign and Keep It Simple

Once your creative variations are ready, the next step is launching - but this is where people overcomplicate things.

Keep it clean, keep it structured.

Best Practices for Launching Creatives

• Use straightforward campaign setups
• Keep targeting simple: location + basic filters
• Let your creative do the heavy lifting
• Run your tests for at least 72 hours
• Expect early winners by Day 3

‍

Top 3 Mistakes to Avoid

‍

1. Poor naming conventions
If your ads aren’t labeled properly, analyzing performance becomes a nightmare. Stick to:
"AdNumber – Hook – Meat"

2. Testing with too little budget
If you don’t spend enough, ads get stuck in the Learning Phase and never optimize.

3. Over-targeting
Most franchise locations don’t need complex targeting.
Simple wins: let the creative drive performance.

‍

3. Score and Scale Your Ad Creatives

After 3–7 days of spending, you’ll have enough data to separate winners from losers.

We score every ad on two key metrics:

Hook Rate

3-Second Video Views ÷ Impressions
This shows how well your hook stops the scroll.

Hold Rate

ThruPlays ÷ 3-Second Views
This measures whether viewers stayed engaged.

‍

Once your data is in a simple Google Sheet:

• Rank your ads by Hook Rate and Hold Rate
• Kill the bottom half
• Study which hooks and meats consistently rise to the top
• Remix winning hooks with other meats and CTAs
• Introduce new hooks weekly
• Validate winners with CPC and CPL to confirm ROI

‍

This is a lightweight but powerful system easy enough for a single franchise location, scalable enough for multi-unit operators, and fully compatible with tight brand guidelines.

‍

Common Objections We Hear From Franchisees

‍

“My franchisor doesn’t allow custom creative.”
We’ve never seen a brand whose guidelines prohibit high-performing ads. You can maintain brand consistency while still customizing hooks and structure.

“I can’t produce that much content.”
You don’t need new content - you need variations.
One 30-minute recording session can yield 30–60 unique creatives.

“I don’t know how to come up with ideas.”
Use this AI prompt we made you to generate hooks, meats, and CTAs for your business instantly.

‍

Payoff

When you follow this system, you eliminate guessing and emotion from your ad strategy. You know what to create, how to test, how to analyze, and how to scale. It’s one of the simplest tweaks a franchise owner can make to start seeing more predictable lead flow.

If you want our team to install this exact system into your franchise or location, click below to book a call.
‍

We set it up in under 14 days.

‍